Championship 2018-19: Week 27
Thu 31 Jan – 23:00: Transfer Window Closes
Sat 2 Feb – 15:00: West Brom v Boro
When mathematician Dr Hannah Fry (no relation) was discussing the origin of numbers with Professor Brian Cox on Radio 4 this week, the whole tactical philosophy of Boro manager Tony Pulis appeared to be called into question when she put forward the hypothesis that perhaps the number zero doesn’t really exist in the universe. Whether the mostly unheard screams of frustration in the empty space of the Riverside stadium (or Ground Zero as it’s sometimes known) would agree with her argument that nothingness doesn’t actually exist is possibly open to conjecture – especially as footballing nothingness has become the underwhelming void into which many have been left to stare.
While Professor Cox’s statement that “even a vacuum is fizzing with activity” may possibly offer some comfort, keen Boro observers in the less rarefied atmosphere of the Riverside are still patiently waiting to detect signs of energetic movement on the pitch. Nevertheless, as supporters occupy themselves counting the ‘missing’ in the North Stand, many are starting to ponder over the presenter’s profound existential question that he so elegantly posed in his ‘Human Universe’ TV series – simply “Why are we here?”
Although, whether some Boro followers would agree with the sentiments of Brian Cox in his earlier work ‘Things can only get better’ will perhaps depend on how the strong their innate sense of pessimism is. The young physicist you may be aware played keyboards in the band D:Ream, whose feel-good hit became the anthem of choice for another much-loved Tony in order to persuade the masses that his vision of hope was authentic and not just another sound bite – sadly it was perhaps their follow-up single ‘Unforgiven’ that will more closely encapsulate Blair’s legacy following his ill-fated venture in Iraq. For many at the Riverside their only hope for a more positive approach is that the infamous ‘hand of history’ taps our own Tony on the shoulder before giving him a slap to bring him to his senses.
Coincidentally, the first recorded appearance of zero was almost 5,000 years ago in the ancient Sumerian culture of Mesopotamia, which now corresponds geographically to Iraq – along with parts of Iran, Syria and Turkey. While the Riverside is no stranger to the concept of zero, you may be interested to learn that Mesopotamia actually means ‘between two rivers’ in Greek – though the rivers in question are the Tigris and the Euphrates, with the land between them known by the Arabs as ‘Al-Jazirah’, or the island. With the great city of this region being Babylon, it’s name is claimed to stem from the Hebrew word for confusion (bavel), which is derived from the story in the Book of Genesis that describes how a Tower in Babel was being built to reach the heavens until God brought a halt to proceedings by causing the people to speak in different languages so they couldn’t understand each other.
Talking of towering confusion and failure to communicate, Tony Pulis’s team of giants once again proved largely ineffectively on the pitch as they played like proverbial strangers at that less ancient cradle of civilisation in the north-east of England. It’s not apparent how Boro contrived to be second best to a mid-table League Two side but it has become a familiar sight to watch the players become less than the sum of their parts as supposedly better quality individuals are still not gelling together in a meaningful way. As the season has progressed, the divide between expectations and what is being delivered appears to have got wider. Each negative display has seen the errors multiply and a change in fortune seems now to be dependent on the arrival of new additions.
However, many doubt whether new blood will ultimately create a radical change in the overall pattern of play or shift the focus towards becoming a more offensive team. There are also structural issues that are unlikely to to be addressed in this transfer window, such as in the full-back positions, and it seems many of the new signings already signed or rumoured to be close to signing are lacking match fitness. The patience of the Riverside crowd has been worn down by months of watching their ponderous team run out of ideas in their quest to add to their nine Championship Riverside goals since August – three of which were actually penalties and also include one own-goal. So with just five goals from open play in five months, it seems the supporters zero tolerance has begun to wear extremely thin.
Needless to say, the journey of that joyless zero from its conception to the cautious mind of the Boro manager has been long and arduous one. Having started life as a simple dot in the Hindu civilisation of India back in the middle of the fifth century, it then spread into what is now Cambodia in the seventh century. It then entered into China and the Islamic countries around a hundred years later, where it became represented by a circle, before making it’s way into Western Europe in the 12th century via Arab traders. How it eventually arrived to South Wales and the industrial landscape of Newport is not clearly described but we may assume a young Anthony Richard Pulis was introduced to the importance of giving nothing away at a very early age.
The failure of the players to be able to express themselves, other than with shrugs of shoulders and holding up of hands, has brought the role of the manager into question. There are charges that managers like Pulis like to keep a tight leash on how their players carry out their duties on the pitch. Whether the Boro manager believes that the solution to his problems is to find players who can better carry out his instructions has not been openly expressed – but he has been prone to pointing the blame at individuals in post-match briefings and only very occasionally claiming his tactics were at fault.
Perhaps the proliferation in the trend to measure players stats and the ability to model the whole game with individual heat maps and biometric data have convinced many coaches that the game of football is about the successful strategic execution of their plan rather than encouraging moments of collective interplay or individual brilliance – not to mention luck. Of course structure is important and players roles and responsibilities are all designed to make them work better as a team. However, at some point they need to play the game in real time and make their own judgements and use their experience to make decisions. A problem may arise if there is a conflict between what they think or what their manager thinks is the right course of action – does the fear of making the wrong decision ultimately outweigh the risk of attempting something off-message?
Interestingly, some managers or coaches are not particularly active on the touchline as responsibility is passed to their players once they cross the white line. Some even prefer to sit in the stands and get an overview of the pattern of play so that they can pass on observations at half-time. Tony Pulis is not that kind of manager and almost plays every ball as he stands in his technical area shouting out instructions, pointing and making all kinds of hand gestures.
The overestimation of a person’s ability to control events is known as the ‘illusion of control’ and was first identified by psychologist Ellen Langer. The illusion is more common in situations where the person knows what the desired outcome should be and is stronger when individuals have an emotional need to control the outcome. In Addition, feedback that emphasises success rather than failure can increase the effect and perhaps Tony Pulis has been conditioned over the years that he has played every ball on the touchline to save his clubs from relegation. Though the good news for those on Teesside feeling helpless as they watch their team underperform – the illusion is weaker for depressed individuals.
With the January transfer window due to close shortly at 11pm on Thursday, the clock is running down in the bid to address the team’s shortcomings. After the early arrival of a not yet match fit Rajiv van La Parra from Huddersfield, it was surprising that he remained an unused sub in the FA Cup tie against Newport as it should have been an ideal opportunity to get him further up to speed. One new recruit who did get a game though was John Obi Mikel, who arrived as a free agent last week and despite his rustiness showed he was still a class act with poise and precision of passing.
Pulis was instrumental in persuading Mikel to come to the Riverside after he apparently “snuck down” to his house and “had a good chat with him” – something that the Boro manager may need to do quite a lot this summer if he’s deployed to persuade Season Card renewals to also come back to the Riverside. As for the Nigerian, Pulis believes he can play anywhere on the pitch before the rather damning indictment of his squad that “There’s not a great deal of competition, in the position he holds himself.” Some supporters were initially worried that Mikel was an unneeded expensive trophy signing but Pulis declared “He’s come on a short-term deal and it isn’t fortunes, I’ll tell you that.” – though as to what “isn’t fortunes” in the magic money tree world of football is anybody’s guess.
Though as one classy defensive midfielder arrives, another has departed with club captain Grant Leadbitter making the move to the Sunderland club he supported as a boy and joined at the age of 16. After seven seasons in a Boro shirt, the 33 year-old Leadbitter paid tribute to everyone at the club for their support: “I couldn’t leave Middlesbrough Football Club without saying my heartfelt thanks to everyone for what has been such a wonderful and memorable part of my career”. It’s perhaps the right time for the fan’s favourite to leave the Riverside as it has become clear he was no longer foremost in Tony Pulis’s plans.
Whether he’ll be joined at the exit by Stewart Downing is still not clear but there is still no news on the situation surrounding his extension clause that prevents him starting Championship games. Though one surprise exit was Danny Batth, who despite his season-long loan at Boro, was still available to be sold by Wolves and Stoke City duly got their man. This has left Pulis with just three recognised central defenders in Ayala, Flint and Fry. While in theory both Friend and Shotton can cover, there is very little cover at full-back to regard them as such – perhaps it will be an opportunity for some academy boys to step up with the highly-rated Nathan Wood being elevated to the full squad. However, one academy player who won’t be getting his chance at Boro is Harry Chapman, who has joined Tony Mowbray’s Blackburn in a permanent move. All of which leaves the Boro recruitment team with plenty to do in the next 48 hours with the latest rumour being pacey striker Isaac Vassell of Birmingham is wanted but given he’s only 5′ 7” it may be as a wide player where he’ll fit into Pulis’s plans – he at least certainly fits the window profile of not being match fit after a recent lay-off due to injury.
So we should know by the weekend if the new-look Tony Pulis team is taking shape or whether he has once again been left frustrated by the failure to sign his targets. Nevertheless, he will need to focus on the first of a series of testing fixtures as he makes the trip to his most recent old club West Brom. When he was dismissed by the Baggies shortly before heading to Teesside, it may come as little surprise to many Boro supporters in how it was reported by the press – The Guardian wrote: “Fans who have long been bored witless by an unattractive brand of football that was no longer yielding the kind of results that led to finishes in 13th, 14th and 10th over the past three seasons have finally got what they wanted.” Before rather mischievously adding “The question now is whether they will regret the decision to sack the first man they would almost certainly approach with a view to extracting them from the current pickle if it was not he who had got them into it in the first place.”
Despite relegation, Pulis’s successor Darren Moore is still in charge at The Hawthorns and his team currently sit one place and three points above Boro. In theory this is probably a promotion six-pointer but I suspect it will be in the eyes of Tony an opportunity for a good away point – preferably a tight 0-0 to remind the ungrateful Baggies followers of what they are missing. OK, Darren Moore may have over compensated as West Brom have already scored 57 goals this season but have conceded 35 in the process. Although, this still leaves them with double the goal difference of Tony Pulis’s side, who have barely hit the net half as many times with 31 scored versus 20 conceded. Should the question be posed over which white-knuckle ride promotion-seeking supporters would prefer to be on board, then I dare say nullifying the opposition with the cult of zero would get nothing more than a shake of the head in the West Midlands – though perhaps a few choice words on Teesside.
After first being appointed as a part-time scout by Bruce Rioch in 1987,
After Ron started as a part-time scout under Bruce Rioch, he was then
As well as being one of Ron’s favourite Boro players, he also
The last player that Ron brought to Middlesbrough before he retired