| Cardiff City | Middlesbrough | ||
| Morrison | 33′ | ||
| Possession Shots On target Corners Fouls |
50% 16 3 5 13 |
Possession Shots On target Corners Fouls |
50% 6 1 3 10 |
Toothless Boro lack bite
This game was to be a real test of Tony Pulis’ Boro. A late undisciplined lunge from sub Adama Traore under GM handed victory to the Bluebirds up at the Riverside earlier in the season in a game where Boro rightfully felt hard done to for their efforts that day. Going into the match it was feeling like a pivotal moment, win and suddenly the hopes of the Play Offs may not be so ridiculous and surely it was time that this Boro squad delivered a blow to someone in the top half.
TP’s main injury concerns this week were restricted to two former Bluebirds, thigh strained Fabio and big Rudy. The Benin striker has seemingly developed a bad back after a stroll on Redcar Beach earlier in the week although there was no truth in the rumour that he twisted said back in an effort to control a lemon top. Speaking of lemons, the main talking point was who would start up front if Gestede was still incapacitated? Bamford hasn’t had an opportunity to lead the line, Britt has looked disinterested at times and his pedantic penalty had many wondering if he may even miss the bus to South Wales.
Wily Warnock had never lost a home game against Boro with any of his clubs. Boro had won three out of their last four away games in the Championship with the loss as a consequence of ten men against Norwich. Cardiff had beaten Sunderland and Bolton in their last two home games but tellingly they had lost the two home games before that to Preston and Fulham so were beatable. Surely today had to be the day when something had to break for Boro especially as the weekend fixture list had thrown together a top half pairing extravaganza meaning points had to be dropped elsewhere.
The Boro Striker conundrum was solved at 2.00pm when the Boro team list revealed that Gestede had recovered from his back strain with Britt benched alongside Paddy. Boro lined up with Besic alongside Grant and Traore on the left supporting Gestede with Howson central and Downing on the right. For a side that can’t create chances removing Bamford to include another defensive midfielder was both head scratching and ominous.
The game started with a quick throw-in to Cardiff and then Traore getting upended much to Grants annoyance which he conveyed to the Ref. A few minutes later Boro won a corner which Grant screwed up completely with a low hit ball that nobody in a Red shirt seemed to be on the same page including Grant!
The opening ten minutes saw things fairly level with neither side dominating proceedings, the Cardiff Striker Zohore was looking a bit of a handful but neither Keeper had been troubled with the nearest attempt being from the result of a Cardiff Shotton style throw in eventually blocked by George. Cardiff did have a few long range punts which were never going to worry Randolph. Meanwhile Adama and Stewy had switched flanks presumably in an effort to disrupt the Cardiff Anti Adama Batteries. On twenty minutes Adama broke and ran towards the Cardiff goalmouth, rounding Ralls but his shot wasn’t up to his usual standard of late with Etheredge in the Cardiff goal gathering.
The “other” Traore in Blue was brought down by Shotton which resulted in a dangerous free kick just outside the Boro box. As the ball was about to be played in Ayala and Morrison were indulging in a bit of pushing and shoving but the cross eventually ended up with the ball on the far side of the Boro box out of danger but the signs were growing that Cardiff were starting to pressurise Boro. The best opportunity for Boro came with 15 minutes left of the first half with Adama (who else) creating a chance for Howson but the score remained 0-0.
Cardiff then had claims for a Penalty as Shotton foolishly brought down Zahore but Ref Darren Bond adjudged it to have happened just outside the box. Hoilett fizzed the resultant free kick across to Morrison who glanced it into Randolph’s goal to make it 1-0. The ball was flying straight into Randolph’s hands and to allow Morrison to simply nick it like he did was very poor from the ROI keeper.
Boro had to clear their heads as Cardiff looked to be growing in confidence and a Boro free kick five minutes later ended up going backwards as if to illustrate the point that Boro had zero creativity. Needing a goal to level things before half time there didn’t appear to be too much on show to give cause for optimism apart from the hope of a bit of Adama magic. Interestingly Cardiff always looked a threat from their set pieces whereas Boro looked just embarrassing and devoid of ideas.
The first booking of the game came just before half time when the Bluebirds Traore was taken out by Mo Besic as the Everton loanee lived up to his stereotyped reputation with the home fans baying for a Red. It was clear that nothing had changed with regards to our attacking effectiveness as Gestede again looked isolated and very unlikely to double his goal tally for the season. Disappointingly, the first half was just a repeat of the same old same old up front for Boro, which is now becoming a growing cause for concern. The second forty-five minutes would require TP to open his mind because as things stood serious sanity questions were being asked and the groundswell of opinion was that offensively it hasn’t and wasn’t working under Pulis. The sacrifice of pace and width for solidity at the back has solved one problem but created another bigger problem intermittently papered over by Adama.
There were unconfirmed reports of an earthquake in South Wales just before half-time and the hope with the travelling army was that it was actually a huge penny dropping with TP. Both sides took to the pitch for the second half with no changes in personnel, surprisingly as Pulis presumably was determined to prove his methodology of no support and no creativity for a non-scoring striker was the correct one. As it was Sol Bamba collided with Gestede in the opening seconds of the half with Rudy looking much the worse for wear after the collision.
A sloppy throw-in from Boro gifted Cardiff another attacking opportunity which put Boro right back where they had finished the first half on the back foot. Stewy broke and put a cross in for Gestede but he mistimed his jump, fortunately the play broke back in Boro’s favour when we then won a corner after a Shotton throw in came off Bamba. The corner predictably came to nothing and Boro were back defending and under pressure once more. Whatever the half-time team talk was and whatever the tactical reasoning behind it was, it was eminently clear that it sucked to use modern day parlance. Gestede was winning nothing, outnumbered two v. one yet again; somehow TP thought once again that this would yield results with a lone striker who can’t score. Boro’s best chance came when Downing should have done better with a poor attempt, which didn’t trouble Etheridge, something which again was pointed out this week on Diasboro.
At this stage Boro looked toothless and out of ideas. Adama was well shackled and there was nothing being offered than even remotely looked like a goal was going to arrive any time soon. Frustratingly this was the same scenario at the end of the first half yet absolutely nothing was done and arguably that same scenario had been present for a series of games now under TP. As bad as Monk was for being clueless about his tactics in general, today Boro’s attack under TP was equally as clueless.
Finally the earthquake must have rattled something as Britt came on for the unremarkable Besic as TP went with three at the back, Stewy wide right, George wide left and Shotton, Ayala and Gibson the three CB’s. The question in my mind was why the radical switch around then when it had been abundantly clear now for weeks that this lone striker tactic never looked like working.
Hoilett then had a great chance with a volley at close range but Randolph managed to get down to it making amends for his earlier flap which gifted Morrison his goal. Warnock was making a sub to rejig his line up to now match Boro’s three at the back with their Traore getting the hook for Peltier. Cardiff were still in control with Adama Traore now seemingly in a more central role, Gestede still pointlessly jumping for headers and Britt just looking lost. For a management “tweak” this one ranked pretty low and as Boro fans we have seen plenty of those in the past to be able to judge. The impact was shall we say somewhat less than earth shattering in contrast to the seismic activity elsewhere in the region.
All Boro hopes now seemed to be resting on throw ins and set pieces yet the Cardiff defence had dealt with high balls all afternoon with cigars and deckchairs out. The pantomime Shotton long throw-ins continued yet their effectiveness was as blunt as they had been all afternoon. A Zahore attack was fortunately thwarted by Grant as he then launched a quick Boro counter attack which ended with Britt on his Assombalonga presumably from shock. Harrison was readied to make his debut in a desperate double substitution with Bamford , which saw Howson and Gestede off in their place. Less than ten minutes left and the tactics were switched around once again.
Another Shotton long throw in ended up yet again with Zahore breaking and Randolph dribbling the ball wide and in doing so had several Boro fans in need of CPR. Scenes were now looking disorganised, chaotic and resembled kick and rush football (or throw and rush in Boro’s case). Cardiff looked comfortable and the more likely to get a second with Hoilet pulling the strings. Warnock wound the clock down by bringing on Halford for Paterson. In stoppage time Boro won a free kick which saw Downing send in the ball which resulted in a bit of a melee with Bennett heading a Bamford effort clear. Harrison then sent the ball back in which was cleared for a corner, which saw a chance from Shotton cleared. The last Boro chance of the game characteristically ended with a cross from Shotton which was on a par with Britt’s penalty last week.
Today saw a weak and unconvincing performance from Boro with zero ability to create or attack. TP has Adama as a solitary attacking threat and without a moment of magic from the erratic Spaniard it is worrying that offensively Tony Pulis seemingly has no more of a clue than his predecessor Garry Monk did. Playing to a set style and fixed game plan is fine if you have the players and skill sets to do so. To try and force it with Players who have not and do not possess the physical traits in some cases and ability in others is just plain stupidity. Running down the season until the summer transfer window is all well and good but fans pay hard earned money to support their team and hope to see some semblance of a fight, not cowering, covering their heads under an avalanche of blows to the head with not so much as a single retaliatory reply.
Not good enough, not even remotely close and if it continues things could get unpleasant well before the summer if this sterile dross continues. Having a long term plan only works if you are here for the long term as GM found out. I was and still am a firm believer that long term TP can bring us back up and keep us up but right now my frustration is bordering on disgust at the state of our attacking organisation and abject lack of ability to carry out a threat. There were too many negative players and non-contributory players selected today. Besic adds nothing that we didn’t already have at the club he is fine as cover for Grant or Clayts, Gestede struggles as he has since he arrived and Assombalonga looks to have all the enthusiasm of a root canal filling at the moment.
Mitigating factors of “not my squad” or “not my players” will only go so far for so long. Season ticket reminders for early birds renewals are being touted, only playing in 60% of the pitch is not a great renewal incentive. Right now questions are being asked of TP and his fruitless tactics, maybe not quite as many as GM had amassed come December but they are growing and fast. Targeting a summer rebuild now is a very dangerous approach. It is too far away and surrendering everything for the sake of playing in a particular preferred style without the attributes to make it work is a dangerous game. Disillusioned supporters don’t renew tickets and those that still go will not sit quietly watching repeated failings with patience and understanding. Football is a results game first and foremost.
Is the measure of Boro’s task
ahead roughly the size of Wales
Boro manager Tony Pulis heads to the familiar land of his fathers on Saturday hoping his team will be in full male voice as they hit the right notes against Cardiff. The size of the task facing Boro as they attempt to make it at least to the play-offs is difficult to quantify – though it’s perhaps the standard measure in these parts that our prospects must be viewed as roughly that of the size of Wales in comparison to the size of the promised land we seek. However, if the relative chances of a play-off spot are indeed equal to an area the size of Wales, then the dream of automatic promotion is quickly becoming greater in magnitude than the lost super-continent of Gondwanaland.
Perhaps our play-off hopes would be better represented by the Slavic mythical island of Buyan, which is believed to have the ability to appear and disappear at will depending on which direction the wind blows – though in Boro’s case our chances seem to disappear with each wave of gloom that floods the Riverside after every defeat. Nevertheless, there is a real fear in Wales that their birthright of being the metaphorical land measurement of choice will soon be gone as the post-Brexit world will instead start adopting the almost equally-sized country of Slovenia as their relative area comparison – where were the buses emblazoned with that pivotal fact in the referendum campaign? It was I believe conspicuous by its absence!
However, when it comes to promotion, many supporters believe their team have already missed the bus, if not fallen under it. Though for all its fits and starts (mainly hissy and false), Boro’s promotion aspirations are still within touching distance as the marathon of a Championship season enters the decisive last third, with many now regretting not taking on enough fluids earlier – albeit of the alcoholic kind. A win against Cardiff would give everyone a second wind and leave them feeling full of beans after optimistically eyeing the run of upcoming fixtures against Hull, Sunderland, Leeds, Birmingham, Barnsley and Brentford. Indeed, Boro must look at these pre-Easter games as probably their last chance to exercise their promotion credentials and put pressure on the teams ahead of them if they want to avoid a hard border between them and the top six emerging.
The main concern is that Boro’s forwards still look short on confidence and Assombalonga’s levels probably reached new depths, which were inversely proportional to the heights achieved by the ball that sailed over the bar from his impromptu spot kick. Bamford is also struggling to believe that he’s going to keep his place in the team that he earlier lost under Monk, albeit a place that takes him away from the position from where he was bestowed Championship player of the season in his first spell at the club. Big Rudy Gestede has yet to prove his role as a target man is nothing more than that of creating an aimless goal for those behind him rather than a means to actually getting one.
When Boro last played Cardiff there was little to indicate that there was any particular gulf in class between the sides – indeed both teams showed little to suggest they were favourites for promotion and it was only Adama coming on as quite literally as a late impact sub that gifted the Bluebirds a late penalty and all three points. The fact that Neil Warnock’s team have opened up a ten point gap over Boro merely suggests that the Teessiders have failed to take their opportunities. Whereas Cardiff have stuck to their task to leave them only one point short of an automatic promotion spot with just under the required 2 points per game. One opposition player Boro supporters may be interested to catch a glimpse of is Yanic Wildschutt and one wonders how he would have fared under the guidance of Tony Pulis given how Adama has flourished since his arrival.
| Cardiff City | Middlesbrough | ||
| Neil Warnock | Tony Pulis | ||
| P31 – W17 – D7 – L7 – F47 – A27 | P31 – W14 – D6 – L11 – F40 – A29 | ||
| Position Points Points per game Projected points |
4th 58 1.9 86 |
Position Points Points per game Projected points |
9th 48 1.6 71 |
| Last 6 Games Bolton (H) Millwall (A) Leeds (A) Sheff Wed (A) Sunderland (H) QPR (A) |
F-T (H-T) 2:0 (2:0) W 1:1 (1:1) D 4:1 (3:0) W 0:0 (0:0) D 4:0 (0:0) W 1:2 (0:0) L |
Last 6 Games Reading (H) Norwich (A) Sheff Wed (H) QPR (A) Fulham (H) Preston (A) |
F-T (H-T) 2:1 (1:0) W 0:1 (0:1) L 0:0 (0:0) D 3:0 (2:0) W 0:1 (0:0) L 3:2 (1:2) W |
Boro have more or less become the Adama Traore show under Tony Pulis and with every MOM performance will come the realistion that with increased attention from the outside comes the ever-growing prospect that he won’t be a Championship player after the summer. One individual cannot a team make, but if Boro can harness a promotion bid in the wake of the high performance showboat waves he’s beginning to make in the football world, then it’s likely to be our only hope of seeing him in Boro shirt next season. Perhaps the worse case scenario is that Adama tears up the division for the rest of the season and Boro fall short as a team – though at least he’ll command a fee several multiples in excess of just getting our money back that many would have settled for a few months ago.
The unknowns in the Boro squad are the new arrivals in January, which if we believe some of the hype surrounding their ability, then they should be offering competition for places in the very near future. It may well be Jack Harrison, who was voted the second best player under 24 in Major League Soccer, is a possible starter on the left given nobody has of yet managed to nail that position. Mo Besic on the other hand will need to compete with Leadbitter, Howson and Clayton for one of the two places available – most likely he’ll be introduced from the bench but that is never usually a game-changing substitution and it may be a while before he gets enough time on the pitch to make an impression.
Overall the defence has picked itself and there no longer appears to be much competition at full-back since Tony Pulis arrived, with George Friend now restored on the left and Ryan Shotton taking over from Christie on the right. Though it seems this week the two Boro full-backs have tried to keep their competitive edge by getting involve in a fierce dual against each other off the pitch – for those who missed this particular battle, George and Ryan went head-to-head in the meanest of contests at Rockliffe Hall as they were tasked with baking and decorating a Victoria sponge cake – this tasty encounter was won by Shotton thanks to his innovative lemon curd variation that knocked Friend’s old school ‘UTB’ decorated effort out of the ballpark.
Older supporters may be trying to recall a similar contest between John Craggs and Terry Cooper, where they both attempted to make an industrial strength cup of tea that allowed the spoon to stand vertically without touching the sides. Indeed, others may even remember the ‘raw meat’ challenge between Ron ‘Chopper’ Harris and Norman ‘Bites Yer Legs’ Hunter, who took it in turns to attempt to remove the opposition forward’s limbs and put them through a mincer before serving them on a plate for the physio. The real man image has certainly changed for the modern player with possibly home-made quiche replacing the pre-match fag and a pint that some fans expected their heroes should adopt to more closely match their own regimes – especially as back in the day, working men frowned upon anything with suspicion that sounded remotely healthy. I just hope the Cardiff players are not expecting a cakewalk as they get up close and personal and pour scorn on the pâtissier passing skills of our full-back bakers. One Boro player still disappointed at being overlooked for the cake challenge and a chance to finally make a name for himself at the club is Lewis Baker – not only is he no longer considered as one of the best 16 players at the club but he’s now not even known as one of best bakers!
Talking of Victorian fruit cakes – Jacob Rees-Mogg may be steeped in the oldest of old school values but he would certainly have little time for those Boro remoaners who would prefer to stay in the Championship this season rather than risk an unmerited exit into the big bad world of the Premier League without being fully prepared. Having failed so miserably last time when we went up, there is a view that the best way to stay up is to arrive as a fully functioning team and make as few changes as possible to your playing style and squad. In some ways we have already seen this season how it has been a difficult process to integrate players and new tactical methods once, let alone twice. Boro still appear to be working out how to play without the luxury of pre-season games to iron out problems and finding the right balance is proving a slow process. Indeed, it’s hard to see many of our current squad being deemed top-flight players should Boro sneak up this season and we’d no doubt be looking at wholesale changes again – forwards who can’t make an impact in the Championship are unlikely to do better at a higher level and midfielders who can’t find a way past journeymen opponents will not face an easier task against fitter, stronger and more skillful players.
The danger for the doubters is that Tony Pulis may be too set in his ways and his conservative approach to tactics may be short on ideas to counter the more modern pragmatic coaches that Boro will face in the top tier. Whether he has run out of new innovations or can still adapt may depend on your viewpoint of whether the game has moved on or not – sometimes old ideas suddenly appear fresh to those who have grown tired of the latest trends that fail to provide improvement. It’s perhaps why those who embody ‘old school’ virtues suddenly appear a refreshing option in the eyes of the public, who hear nothing in the same old noises to offer them hope or catch their attention. Whatever the message, people are seemingly drawn to characters who appear to talk with enthusiasm and confidence – the question is whether what they represent is built on imagination or just the lack of it.
Take our friend Jacob Rees-Mogg, who is all of a sudden being talked of in the media as the next man to lead the country, it emerged last year to much amusement that he named his sixth child ‘Sixtus’ (latin for ‘the sixth’) and it’s hard to say whether that was out of imagination or just out of desperation from running out of ideas? Though given the child’s full name, Sixtus Dominic Boniface Christopher, I suspect he has some magical random name generating machine in his attic that he consults in Latin on such matters – especially if you look at the names conjured up for his other five children – Peter Theodore Alphege, Mary Anne Charlotte Emma, Thomas Wentworth Somerset Dunstan, Anselm Charles Fitzwilliam and Alfred Wulfric Leyson Pius. Though it looks like his wife may have been charged with naming their daughter Mary. However, his sons may consider themselves lucky that they didn’t attend Linthorpe junior school in the early seventies instead of Eton or Hogwarts (or wherever the elite send their kids these days) – as I suspect as they adjusted their pinstriped waistcoats while waiting for their name to be called in the morning register they may as well have just stuck a big piece of paper on their backs with ‘kick me’ written on it with the Latin translation in a fluorescent red felt-tip pen.
The question that now remains to be answered is whether Tony Pulis represents both the past and the future in terms of his footballing philosophy. Has the game moved on to the point where old school managers only know enough to limit the risk of defeat or do they in fact know how to make less complicated more effective teams from the pool of limited talented players at their disposal. Boro’s problem is perhaps convincing some of the key players that they can be effective in a system that they may suspect is not where their long term futures lies and are not buying into the new man. Alternatively, have they flattered to deceive and are they indeed only good players when a manager plays to their limited strengths. It may well be that showing the right character will be increasingly important in the coming months, as I expect with three games in a week, the season is coming closer to being defined one way or the other.
So as Boro survey the promotion landscape will they map their journey into the play-offs with a South Wales sized victory? Or will the play-off aspirations of a small town in Europe be pushed by the Bluebirds further over the proverbial white cliffs? As usual your predictions on score, scorers and team selection – plus will the old school ties of Pulis and Warnock see them help each other to a point in a game of defensive solidarity.



